Emily Oster, PhD

2 minute read Emily Oster, PhD
author-pic

Emily Oster, PhD

Are Audio-Only Baby Monitors Worth It?

Q&A on listening

Emily Oster, PhD

2 minute read

I’ve watched friends obsessively watch their little ones on video monitors and feel like it can impede taking time to decompress away from baby. I’m seven months pregnant and we are thinking of getting an audio-only monitor. Any reason we should not go that route if that feels healthier to us?

EBR

Reading your question, I am transported back to the first months of my daughter’s life, trying to relax and watch TV with my spouse and checking the video monitor every four seconds. I’m reminded of that, and of the experience of trying to mount it in a way that got a good view. Like we are some kind of cinematographers, trying to get the shot. Anyway, my point is: I see your point.

pixelshot

Baby monitors do not have a documented safety value. Instead, the value is some combination of being able to hear the baby when they wake up and need to eat, and the peace of mind that at least some people get from being able to watch the baby. Monitors like Nanit collect other data that can be used to optimize sleep in various ways and, probably more so, to provide additional peace of mind. 

Basically: the monitor is for you. So you should use whatever monitor gives you the most peace of mind. 

Community Guidelines
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
A crib with a raincloud mobile hung above it.

Jan. 20, 2022

2 minute read

Should I Put My Baby in Their Own Room After Four Months?

Can you comment on this article, which reports on a study about how babies sleep better if they’re in their Read more

Baby on parent's lap on plane

Mar. 3, 2025

2 minute read

Is It Safe to Fly with My Baby During a Measles Outbreak?

I live in Canada and am flying to the U.S. with my five-month-old next week. However, the various measles outbreaks Read more

A baby being tucked in a car seat

Updated on Jan. 10, 2025

3 minute read

Is It Unsafe to Wear a Coat in a Car Seat?

I’m really curious about the data when it comes to the impact of babies/toddlers/children and even adults wearing coats under Read more

A saline spray and tissues in a colorful background

Updated on Jan. 31, 2025

2 minute read

Is Saline Nasal Spray Safe for Babies?

At the start of last winter, our baby started waking up with blood on her nose and face due to Read more