Prenatal vitamins! If there is any product that seems designed to prey on our fears, it is this one. You’re newly pregnant, or trying to get pregnant. You want to do it right — yet there are so many things that feel complicated and new. Everyone agrees you need prenatal vitamins, so you get them. But do you want to be that person who just … buys the generic prenatal vitamins? You’re a sitting duck for ads that promise that some particular prenatal vitamins are going to give you the absolute best baby.
And that best baby is going to cost you, or it might. On Amazon, prenatal vitamins range from 11 cents per pill (Nature Made) up to 83 cents (New Chapter, for women over 35). The question you face: is there any reason to pay eight times as much for one pill over another?
Setting the stage: Vitamins
Before we get into prenatals, I want to very briefly address the overall issue of vitamins. For more on this, please visit this post, which is all about vitamins in general. The short summary is: In the vast majority of cases, people do not need vitamins. Unless you have a specific vitamin deficiency — which is extremely rare for people who have reliable food access — you do not benefit from more vitamins through supplementation.
True vitamin deficiencies can be dangerous and even deadly. If you’re on a boat in the 16th century, eating only hardtack, you could get scurvy and die. But your need for (in this case) vitamin C to prevent scurvy is almost certainly met by what you’re eating. A few packets of ketchup a day would be enough to get all the vitamin C you need.
What I’m saying is that vitamins are mostly pointless for people in general, and before you write back about this to indicate your disagreement, please read the original post.
There are some components of prenatal vitamins that you do need, some that are questionable, and many that are a waste. Let’s review.
Items you definitely or very likely need
The number one thing you should have in your prenatal vitamin is folic acid (or folate). Folic acid has been shown in randomized trials to reduce the risk of neural tube defects by between 70% and 95%. Neural tube defects (like spina bifida) are rare already, but supplementation pushes them close to zero. The recommended dose is at least 400 micrograms (mcg) per day; higher is also okay.
There is a lot of debate on the internet about folic acid versus folate. Folate is the nutrient you need, and it’s found in food. Folic acid is a less expensive synthetic form of folate that your body can break down into folate. Prenatal vitamins can also contain folate directly. For some people, a genetic variant may limit their ability to break down folic acid into folate. However, there isn’t any strong evidence to suggest that folate is better — this suggests that the vast majority of people are able to use folic acid to a sufficient degree. And the randomized trials all use folic acid. There isn’t anything wrong with folate, but it’s also unnecessary to pay more for it.
Iron (+ vitamin C)
Anemia (low iron) is a common issue for women in general and pregnant and postpartum women in particular. Anemia can cause low energy, fatigue, depression, and dizziness. Most pregnant women should be screened for low iron and in extreme cases may need more than supplementation. But a very large share of women would benefit from an iron supplement during pregnancy. An easy way to get it is in your prenatal vitamin.
You also want vitamin C in your vitamin because it helps absorb iron. It’s otherwise useless (see below), but it matters here.
(Yes, you can have too much iron, although it is not common. This is why a blood test is useful.)
Vitamin B12 if you do not eat animal products
Vitamin B12 is necessary if you do not eat animal products, as that’s the only place to get it otherwise. This is a supplement you’re likely taking regularly if you’re in this group, but it’s especially important in pregnancy.
Specific vitamin deficiencies
I want to call out: you might have a specific vitamin deficiency. It’s not that likely! But if you do, you should be taking a supplement, whether pregnant or not. If you eat a solely plant-based diet, there are a few other nutrients (iodine, zinc) that you’re more likely to be deficient in. Again, this is broader than pregnancy.
Items with mixed evidence, or theory but no evidence
DHA is an omega-3 fatty acid that is found in cold-water fish. It’s also possible to get it in supplement form through fish oil. There is a lot of speculation that DHA consumption during pregnancy could improve kids’ cognitive development.
The data is, at best, pretty mixed. There is, for example, a sizable randomized trial with follow-up at 18 months, 4 years, and 7 years that showed no impacts of DHA supplementation on cognitive test performance. Then we have a second randomized trial, which shows impacts on one cognitive test but not another at age 5. Overall, as a Cochrane review of trials points out, there is little evidence to support the value of DHA in development. (There is plenty of data showing that DHA consumption and child development is correlated, but that evidence is unlikely to be causal, due to differences across women.)
However: fish oil supplements do seem to reduce the risk of preterm birth in trials. We also see this reduction from fish consumption, and it seems to be larger for people who have low omega-3s to begin with. This is probably the best reason to consider a prenatal that includes DHA.
Choline is a nutrient found in a variety of animal products, especially fatty ones (salmon, eggs, beef liver, etc.). It’s important for brain function, so there is the idea that it might also be important for fetal brain development. There is some animal model evidence that might support this. There are also a couple of (very small) randomized trials in humans that show impacts of supplementation on cognitive function in elementary school.
I’m skeptical of these studies for some of the reasons discussed in this post on p-hacking. The studies are not really large enough to be powered to find the effects that they do, so this makes me worry about publication bias. In the end, it feels like a theoretical possibility that is probably not important in practice.
To the extent that there is value in choline supplementation, it would likely be greater if you currently consumed fewer animal products in your diet.
Vitamin D and calcium
There are theoretical reasons why calcium might be beneficial during pregnancy, mostly if you consume a diet with very low calcium. Similarly, vitamin D is broadly relevant for bone health, so it seems like it might be important. But we don’t have any concrete data suggesting there is some known threshold that matters.
Things with no evidence
A typical prenatal vitamin contains most or all of the above nutrients, plus a lot of other stuff. This includes (typically) vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin K, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, biotin, magnesium, and zinc. Sometimes there are others.
There is no compelling evidence that these are necessary in pregnancy or otherwise, for nearly all people. It’s not that they are bad for you (at least not at the levels they are in the vitamins); it’s just that they are unnecessary. You definitely should not pay more for them.
The ideal prenatal
Here’s what you want in your prenatal vitamin if you are a consumer of animal products:
- Folic acid
- Vitamin C
- DHA (for the preterm birth benefits)
If you do not consume animal products, add B12, plus a few others depending on your diet.
That is it. Any prenatal vitamin that contains these is enough. And lest you be concerned that you need to buy an expensive prenatal because some vitamins are created differently, they aren’t. Vitamins are just vitamins. If they come in a fancy pill that looks like it’s full of gold (I’m looking at you, Ritual), it does not make them any different.
This list is good to keep in mind if you’re struggling with getting these pills down, especially during the first trimester. Folic acid is by far the most important. If you just took a single-ingredient folic acid pill, you would get a huge share of the most evidence-based benefits.
So that’s it: prenatals are simple! Save money by buying something cheap. Trust me that there will be plenty of adorable onesies to spend it on later.
P.S. Before you ask, no, you do not need to take your prenatal after birth, even if you are breastfeeding. You might need iron, but the rest is a waste.
- Vitamins are vitamins. Fancier vitamins are not better.
- Folic acid is the most important prenatal ingredient.
- Iron (with vitamin C) and DHA are also nice to have.
- Other included ingredients have only weak or no evidence to support their use.