Emily Oster

2 min Read Emily Oster

Emily Oster

Does Getting Sick Give You More Immunity Than Getting a Vaccine?

Q&A on shots and viruses

Emily Oster

2 min Read

I was having a discussion with a colleague who said that it is a well-documented fact that immunity deriving from getting sick is much stronger than immunity from vaccination. I did some research but couldn’t find anything on the subject. Can you help?

Luisa

The answer to this question depends slightly on what vaccine and virus you are talking about. But it is true that for many viruses, the immunity from getting sick is greater than the immunity from a single vaccine. This is why, for example, we give kids two measles vaccines as the standard dose, whereas a single infection with measles would provide lifelong protection.

But measles is also a good example of why it’s important to weigh the costs and benefits. Two doses of the measles vaccine provides virtually complete protection against getting measles. The side effects of the vaccine are minimal, and decades of experience has shown it to be safe. Actually getting measles is not a good substitute. It can be very serious, even fatal. 

The reason illness is often more potent than vaccination is that when you get sick, your body produces a big response — lots of antibodies, since you’re really ill. With vaccines, we aim to get an adequate response but not to overwhelm your system, which would produce more side effects. So the smaller dose leads to less potency, and this is why we often need multiple doses.  

There are some vaccines where the vaccination response is actually better (like HPV), so it doesn’t always work this way, but it does for many vaccines. But, again, the vaccines have the distinct advantage of not involving being sick, or getting others sick. 

Community Guidelines
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
A parent looks worried as she talks to a doctor on the phone while placing her palm on the forehead of a sick child.

Oct. 27, 2022

8 min Read

Why Are We All So Sick?

RSV, norovirus, the fluÑoh my

Smiling young child flexes and shows of a bandaid from a recent vaccination.

Sep. 25, 2023

13 min Read

Your Guide to Vaccines During Pregnancy and Early Childhood

There was a time — let’s say, 2019 — when people did not talk as much about vaccines. It’s not Read more

A parent looks worried as she talks to a doctor on the phone while placing her palm on the forehead of a sick child.

Nov. 13, 2023

4 min Read

How Often Do Kids Get Sick?

This Halloween, I came across an Instagram reel with the caption “the scariest costume of all.” The costume, worn by Read more

A toddler gets a shot from a doctor

Dec. 19, 2023

3 min Read

Can My Kid Get a Flu Shot While Sick?

My almost-2-year-old finally had his appointment for a flu shot this morning (after rescheduling five times over the past two Read more