Emily Oster

9 min Read Emily Oster

Emily Oster

Are Frenotomies Worth It?

Data on the benefits and risks of fixing tongue ties

Emily Oster

9 min Read

What does the data say about the increasingly common practice of cutting tongue-ties in infants to improve breastfeeding success? Before getting into it, I want to acknowledge where this starts from — namely, from the fact that breastfeeding is often, especially at the start, difficult. Milk can take time to come in, and many infants (and their moms) struggle to get the hang of a good latch. This can lead to painful nipples and to inefficient feeding, and then low weight gain.

There are many baseline solutions to this: lactation consultants can help, as can pediatricians and doulas. Formula supplementation can also be supportive during this period.

The experience of struggling to nurse can be emotionally fraught — I say this from experience — and it is natural to look for solutions. Which, I think, may explain the growth over time of tongue-tie procedures, called frenotomy. This procedure, in which a small cut is made in the underside of the tongue to allow it to move more freely, is billed as a solution for improving breastfeeding success and lessening nipple pain. Over the past decade, use of the procedure has increased. There isn’t enough systematic data to be clear on how much, but individual practice patterns show an increase in young babies (0 to 2 months) in particular. This certainly does not reflect a change in how infants’ mouths are shaped over this period. It may reflect overuse of the procedure or it could reflect an evidence-based change in our understanding of its value.

Several weeks ago, the New York Times published a long and quite scary article on this topic. The premise of the article is that the procedure is overused by people greedy for profit. It paints a dark picture, including some difficult-to-read stories that seem to reflect an almost violent use of the procedure on babies. The article does not do a detailed review of the data, however, on either benefits or harms.

My goal here is to review both the evidence on benefits and what we know about risk.

Evidence on benefits

There are a number of reasons why doctors might perform a frenotomy. It sometimes comes up in the context of speech issues for older children, for example (we will leave these issues for another time). But the most common reason is for infants who are having difficulties breastfeeding. This might be identified by infants having trouble getting enough milk or in cases when breastfeeding is painful for mom. The procedure involves cutting the tissue that connects the bottom of the tongue to the bottom of the mouth.

(There are many nuances here — tongue-ties can be more or less severe, attached further to the front or to the back of the mouth, and there are also lip-ties. The already limited evidence does not typically distinguish among these.)

Big-picture summary: We have little good evidence on the benefits of frenotomy.

It’s possible to imagine a good study to evaluate this. Such a study would recruit a large sample of infants with breastfeeding issues. They would be randomly allocated to either frenotomy or to general breastfeeding support. They would be followed over time, and outcomes would include continuation of breastfeeding, pain reported by mom, and some objective measurement of breastfeeding efficacy.

There is a recent trial that tried to do something quite close to this, called FROSTTIE. Unfortunately, it ran into two problems. First, it was started right before the COVID-19 pandemic, and ultimately recruitment stalled and the authors were unable to come close to the planned sample size.

Second, and more problematic, a large share of the control group — the group not allocated to the frenotomy — got one anyway: 74% of this group opted for the procedure. In a trial like this, the randomization is not enforced; people are randomized into one group, but they can choose differently. The hope is that enough people stick with their assigned group that you have differences on average. Here, since such a large share of the control group actually did have the procedure, it is hard to learn much from comparing the two groups. The authors didn’t find any evidence of any differences in breastfeeding outcomes, but the limitations of the trial make that hard to draw conclusions from.

The failure of this trial was disappointing, because the data that comes before it is unconvincing. There is a long review article, and a review including the small number of randomized studies. If we focus on the randomized trials, the evidence varies. In three randomized trials in which breastfeeding effectiveness was evaluated by an external observer, two found no differences and one found some small differences.

There are studies that show much more positive results. Generally, these rely on maternal reports without randomization. For example: data from Denmark found that 78% of women indicated a moderate to high improvement in symptoms after the procedure. This type of before-after design, especially with self-reports, is unreliable. Without a control group, we do not know if things would have improved otherwise. Self-reports can be driven by a desire to think things have improved, even if the objective reality is the same.

Within the randomized data, there is more consistent evidence of reductions in maternal pain. This is perhaps not surprising, since it also relies exclusively on self-reports.

All of the existing studies have one fundamental drawback: short follow-up, often only a few days. The goal of this procedure, in a broad sense, is to improve the experience of breastfeeding so people are able to do it longer. We have no reliable evidence either way on whether this is true.

(Sidebar: All of this focuses on breastfeeding success, but if you’re struggling here, it’s worth re-reading this chapter from Cribsheet to be clear that many of the benefits of breastfeeding you hear about are overstated.)

Evidence on harms

In the systematic data reviews, harms from this procedure are limited. A comprehensive look at harms from a large number of studies and case reviews noted that most studies found no significant harm or minimal harms. Minor, limited bleeding was the most common. A 2020 study looked for case reports of serious complications from this procedure from 1965 to 2020 and found 34 infants with serious complications. This is a very small share of the infants who have had this procedure. Most complications involved issues with feeding post-surgery.

This isn’t to say that the procedure has no risks. Any surgical procedure entails some small risk, and we can see from the limited case reports that there are examples of more significant complications (like those highlighted by the New York Times). However, in the vast majority of cases, this procedure doesn’t result in harm.

I think this is important to say because I’ve heard from a number of people basically asking, Did I make a huge mistake doing this? Have I done something terrible to my child? Should I be looking for long-term negative consequences? The answer is no. The procedure may not have helped, but there is no reason to beat yourself up.

Summary

What we have here is a procedure with limited systematic evidence to support it, but also limited evidence of harm, and a lot of people who think it works. Breastfeeding often gets easier over time, or with advice about position and latching, so even if this procedure has no impact at all, it is still likely that many people will find breastfeeding improves afterward.

Put simply: the placebo effect is powerful. We know from countless other settings that people who are treated with sugar pills, or sham procedures, can receive significant benefits just from thinking they are being treated. It may be that this is a big part of what is happening here.

If that is true, we get into a philosophical discussion. Is it ethical to perform this procedure if it improves people’s experiences, even if that is just a placebo? Generally in medicine, the answer to this is no. But it’s slippery. Imagine you thought this actually worked for a small share of people and worked due to a placebo effect for a large share, but you didn’t know who was who. Then it might feel perfectly okay to do the procedure widely.

Of course, we like evidence. The placebo effect is interesting, but I’d like to know if it works for real.

This is proving hard.

The fact that many people — both individuals and providers — feel that this works is, paradoxically, making it more difficult to figure out if it actually works. The main problem in the FROSTTIE trial was that people wanted the procedure so much that they were not willing to stick with their assigned group if they weren’t assigned to get it. This is a huge problem for research design. The authors of that trial end their article discussing it by saying we need alternative approaches to evaluate this, which seems spot-on to me. As usual when we talk about breastfeeding, we do not have enough evidence-based support — whether it’s mastitisbreast milk storage, or this issue — we don’t know enough and we deserve more.

In the end, the New York Times is almost certainly right that we’re doing more of these procedures than are necessary. A frenotomy should not be a first-line option — it should be considered only after a serious evaluation of the infant and of the breastfeeding issues. If it is suggested to you, you might consider a second opinion.

Bottom line

  • There is limited evidence that frenotomy procedures improve breastfeeding efficacy.
  • There is slightly more evidence on impacts on maternal pain, but this is entirely based on self-reports.
  • In systematic data, the harms of the procedure are minimal.
  • It should not be a first-line treatment for breastfeeding problems.
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
A baby sticks out their tongue and smiles.

Oct 01 2020

5 min read

Tongue Tie

Plus updating the last question around babies.

Emily Oster
An illustration of a mouth with a tongue sticking out on a blue background.

Oct 07 2022

2 min read

Should My Baby Get a Frenectomy?

My three-month-old was diagnosed with tongue- and lip-ties. In the absence of feeding problems (he’s nursed like a champ from Read more

Emily Oster
A mother tries to breast feed while her baby cries.

Oct 23 2020

2 min read

Tongue Tie and Breastfeeding Pain

I recently wrote about tongue tie for ParentData. I would briefly summarize the main point of that post as there Read more

Emily Oster
A baby with a huge smile shows off their two bottom teeth.

Sep 27 2023

2 min read

Do I Have to Stop Night Feeding?

At our 12-month well child check for our son, our pediatrician advised me to stop breastfeeding at night because of Read more

Emily Oster

Instagram

left right
Milestones. We celebrate them in pregnancy, in parenting, and they’re a fun thing to celebrate at work too. Just a couple years ago I couldn’t have foreseen what this community would grow into. Today, there are over 400,000 of you here—asking questions, making others feel seen wherever they may be in their journey, and sharing information that supports data > panic. 

It has been a busy summer for the team at ParentData. I’d love to take a moment here to celebrate the 400k milestone. As I’ve said before, it’s more important than ever to put good data in the hands of parents. 

Share this post with a friend who could use a little more data, and a little less parenting overwhelm. 

📷 Me and my oldest, collaborating on “Expecting Better”

Milestones. We celebrate them in pregnancy, in parenting, and they’re a fun thing to celebrate at work too. Just a couple years ago I couldn’t have foreseen what this community would grow into. Today, there are over 400,000 of you here—asking questions, making others feel seen wherever they may be in their journey, and sharing information that supports data > panic.

It has been a busy summer for the team at ParentData. I’d love to take a moment here to celebrate the 400k milestone. As I’ve said before, it’s more important than ever to put good data in the hands of parents.

Share this post with a friend who could use a little more data, and a little less parenting overwhelm.

📷 Me and my oldest, collaborating on “Expecting Better”
...

I spend a lot of time talking people down after they read the latest panic headline. In most cases, these articles create an unnecessary amount of stress around pregnancy and parenting. This is my pro tip for understanding whether the risk presented is something you should really be worrying about.

Comment “link” for an article with other tools to help you navigate risk and uncertainty.

#emilyoster #parentdata #riskmanagement #parentstruggles #parentingstruggles

I spend a lot of time talking people down after they read the latest panic headline. In most cases, these articles create an unnecessary amount of stress around pregnancy and parenting. This is my pro tip for understanding whether the risk presented is something you should really be worrying about.

Comment “link” for an article with other tools to help you navigate risk and uncertainty.

#emilyoster #parentdata #riskmanagement #parentstruggles #parentingstruggles
...

Here’s why I think you don’t have to throw away your baby bottles.

Here’s why I think you don’t have to throw away your baby bottles. ...

Drop your toddlers favorite thing right now in the comments—then grab some popcorn.

Original thread source: Reddit @croc_docs

Drop your toddlers favorite thing right now in the comments—then grab some popcorn.

Original thread source: Reddit @croc_docs
...

Just keep wiping.

Just keep wiping. ...

Dr. Gillian Goddard sums up what she learned from the Hot Flash  S e x  Survey! Here are some key data takeaways:

🌶️ Among respondents, the most common s e x u a l frequency was 1 to 2 times per month, followed closely by 1 to 2 times per week
🌶️ 37% have found their sweet spot and are happy with the frequency of s e x they are having
🌶️ About 64% of respondents were very or somewhat satisfied with the quality of the s e x they are having

Do any of these findings surprise you? Let us know in the comments!

#hotflash #intimacy #midlifepleasure #parentdata #relationships

Dr. Gillian Goddard sums up what she learned from the Hot Flash S e x Survey! Here are some key data takeaways:

🌶️ Among respondents, the most common s e x u a l frequency was 1 to 2 times per month, followed closely by 1 to 2 times per week
🌶️ 37% have found their sweet spot and are happy with the frequency of s e x they are having
🌶️ About 64% of respondents were very or somewhat satisfied with the quality of the s e x they are having

Do any of these findings surprise you? Let us know in the comments!

#hotflash #intimacy #midlifepleasure #parentdata #relationships
...

Should your kid be in a car seat on the plane? The AAP recommends that you put kids under 40 pounds into a car seat on airplanes. However, airlines don’t require car seats.

Here’s what we know from a data standpoint:
✈️ The risk of injury to a child on a plane without a carseat is very small (about 1 in 250,000)
✈️ A JAMA Pediatrics paper estimates about 0.4 child air crash deaths per year might be prevented in the U.S. with car seats 
✈️ Cars are far more dangerous than airplanes! The same JAMA paper suggests that if 5% to 10% of families switched to driving, then we would expect more total deaths as a result of this policy. 

If you want to buy a seat for your lap infant, or bring a car seat for an older child, by all means do so! But the additional protection based on the numbers is extremely small.

#parentdata #emilyoster #flyingwithkids #flyingwithbaby #carseats #carseatsafety

Should your kid be in a car seat on the plane? The AAP recommends that you put kids under 40 pounds into a car seat on airplanes. However, airlines don’t require car seats.

Here’s what we know from a data standpoint:
✈️ The risk of injury to a child on a plane without a carseat is very small (about 1 in 250,000)
✈️ A JAMA Pediatrics paper estimates about 0.4 child air crash deaths per year might be prevented in the U.S. with car seats
✈️ Cars are far more dangerous than airplanes! The same JAMA paper suggests that if 5% to 10% of families switched to driving, then we would expect more total deaths as a result of this policy.

If you want to buy a seat for your lap infant, or bring a car seat for an older child, by all means do so! But the additional protection based on the numbers is extremely small.

#parentdata #emilyoster #flyingwithkids #flyingwithbaby #carseats #carseatsafety
...

SLEEP DATA 💤 PART 2: Let’s talk about naps. Comment “Link” for an article on what we learned about daytime sleep!

The first three months of life are a chaotic combination of irregular napping, many naps, and a few brave or lucky souls who appear to have already arrived at a two-to-three nap schedule. Over the next few months, the naps consolidate to three and then to two. By the 10-to-12-month period, a very large share of kids are napping a consistent two naps per day. Over the period between 12 and 18 months, this shifts toward one nap. And then sometime in the range of 3 to 5 years, naps are dropped. What I think is perhaps most useful about this graph is it gives a lot of color to the average napping ages that we often hear. 

Note: Survey data came from the ParentData audience and users of the Nanit sleep monitor system. Both audiences skew higher-education and higher-income than the average, and mostly have younger children. The final sample is 14,919 children. For more insights on our respondents, read the full article.

SLEEP DATA 💤 PART 2: Let’s talk about naps. Comment “Link” for an article on what we learned about daytime sleep!

The first three months of life are a chaotic combination of irregular napping, many naps, and a few brave or lucky souls who appear to have already arrived at a two-to-three nap schedule. Over the next few months, the naps consolidate to three and then to two. By the 10-to-12-month period, a very large share of kids are napping a consistent two naps per day. Over the period between 12 and 18 months, this shifts toward one nap. And then sometime in the range of 3 to 5 years, naps are dropped. What I think is perhaps most useful about this graph is it gives a lot of color to the average napping ages that we often hear.

Note: Survey data came from the ParentData audience and users of the Nanit sleep monitor system. Both audiences skew higher-education and higher-income than the average, and mostly have younger children. The final sample is 14,919 children. For more insights on our respondents, read the full article.
...

Happy Father’s Day to the Fathers and Father figures in our ParentData community! 

Tag a Dad who this holiday may be tricky for. We’re sending you love. 💛

Happy Father’s Day to the Fathers and Father figures in our ParentData community!

Tag a Dad who this holiday may be tricky for. We’re sending you love. 💛
...

“Whilst googling things like ‘new dad sad’ and ‘why am I crying new dad,’ I came across an article written by a doctor who had trouble connecting with his second child. I read the symptoms and felt an odd sense of relief.” Today we’re bringing back an essay by Kevin Maguire of @newfatherhood about his experience with paternal postpartum depression. We need to demystify these issues in order to change things for the better. Comment “Link” for a DM to read his full essay.

#parentdata #postpartum #postpartumdepression #paternalmentalhealth #newparents #emilyoster

“Whilst googling things like ‘new dad sad’ and ‘why am I crying new dad,’ I came across an article written by a doctor who had trouble connecting with his second child. I read the symptoms and felt an odd sense of relief.” Today we’re bringing back an essay by Kevin Maguire of @newfatherhood about his experience with paternal postpartum depression. We need to demystify these issues in order to change things for the better. Comment “Link” for a DM to read his full essay.

#parentdata #postpartum #postpartumdepression #paternalmentalhealth #newparents #emilyoster
...

What does the data say about children who look more like one parent? Do they also inherit more character traits and mannerisms from that parent? Let’s talk about it 🔎

#emilyoster #parentdata #parentingcommunity #lookslikedaddy #lookslikemommy

What does the data say about children who look more like one parent? Do they also inherit more character traits and mannerisms from that parent? Let’s talk about it 🔎

#emilyoster #parentdata #parentingcommunity #lookslikedaddy #lookslikemommy
...

SLEEP DATA 💤 We asked you all about your kids’ sleep—and got nearly 15,000 survey responses to better understand kids’ sleep patterns. Comment “Link” for an article that breaks down our findings!

This graph shows sleeping location by age. You’ll notice that for the first three months, most kids are in their own sleeping location in a parent’s room. Then, over the first year, this switches toward their own room. As kids age, sharing a room with a sibling becomes more common. 

Head to the newsletter for more and stay tuned for part two next week on naps! 🌙

#parentdata #emilyoster #childsleep #babysleep #parentingcommunity

SLEEP DATA 💤 We asked you all about your kids’ sleep—and got nearly 15,000 survey responses to better understand kids’ sleep patterns. Comment “Link” for an article that breaks down our findings!

This graph shows sleeping location by age. You’ll notice that for the first three months, most kids are in their own sleeping location in a parent’s room. Then, over the first year, this switches toward their own room. As kids age, sharing a room with a sibling becomes more common.

Head to the newsletter for more and stay tuned for part two next week on naps! 🌙

#parentdata #emilyoster #childsleep #babysleep #parentingcommunity
...

Weekends are good for extra cups of ☕️ and listening to podcasts. I asked our team how they pod—most people said on walks or during chores. What about you?

Comment “Link” to subscribe to ParentData with Emily Oster, joined by some excellent guests.

#parentdata #parentdatapodcast #parentingpodcast #parentingtips #emilyoster

Weekends are good for extra cups of ☕️ and listening to podcasts. I asked our team how they pod—most people said on walks or during chores. What about you?

Comment “Link” to subscribe to ParentData with Emily Oster, joined by some excellent guests.

#parentdata #parentdatapodcast #parentingpodcast #parentingtips #emilyoster
...

Humility. That’s why. That’s the whole reason.

#emilyoster #secondbaby #parentingjokes #parentinghumor

Humility. That’s why. That’s the whole reason.

#emilyoster #secondbaby #parentingjokes #parentinghumor
...

Bug season is upon us. Besides annoyance, this can bring up safety concerns, particularly with ticks. They are carriers of diseases, most notably Lyme disease. So what’s the best course of action?

Prevention is key! I suggest:
⭐ Regular tick checks
⭐ Using bug sprays with DEET 
⭐ Wearing long sleeves and pants in the woods

Some parents worry about DEET, but repellants with up to 30% DEET are recommended by both the CDC and AAP. The data says you’re in the clear, so go for it. Enjoy your summer!

#parentdata #emilyoster #tickseason #bugbites #bugspray

Bug season is upon us. Besides annoyance, this can bring up safety concerns, particularly with ticks. They are carriers of diseases, most notably Lyme disease. So what’s the best course of action?

Prevention is key! I suggest:
⭐ Regular tick checks
⭐ Using bug sprays with DEET
⭐ Wearing long sleeves and pants in the woods

Some parents worry about DEET, but repellants with up to 30% DEET are recommended by both the CDC and AAP. The data says you’re in the clear, so go for it. Enjoy your summer!

#parentdata #emilyoster #tickseason #bugbites #bugspray
...